In the United States, exposure to media violence is becoming an inescapable component of children’s lives. With the rise in new technologies, such as tablets and new gaming platforms, children and adolescents increasingly are exposed to what is known as “virtual violence.” This form of violence is not experienced physically; rather, it is experienced in realistic ways via new technology and ever more intense and realistic games. The American Academy of Pediatrics continues to be concerned about children’s exposure to virtual violence and the effect it has on their overall health and well-being. This policy statement aims to summarize the current state of scientific knowledge regarding the effects of virtual violence on children’s attitudes and behaviors and to make specific recommendations for pediatricians, parents, industry, and policy makers.
- CI —
- confidence interval
Media violence is woven into the fabric of American children’s lives. As recently as the year 2000, every G-rated movie contained violence, as did 60% of prime time television shows.1 In 1998, the most comprehensive assessment of screen violence was completed. It estimated that the typical child will have seen 8000 murders and 100 000 other acts of violence (including rape and assault) before middle school.2 The 1998 report was limited to television, which was appropriate at the time, because it was the primary platform exposing children to violence. Today’s children experience screen violence on many different platforms, including computers, video games, and touch-screen devices, in addition to longstanding platforms, such as televisions. Increasingly, media researchers and pediatricians refer to children’s “media diets” as a way of conveying the amount and type of media that is consumed. Like food diets, media diets can be healthy or unhealthy, balanced or imbalanced, or healthy in quality but unhealthy in quantity.
This policy statement uses the term “virtual violence” to discuss all forms of violence that are not experienced physically and, in particular, to encompass the extent to which children increasingly experience violence in more realistic ways than they have before. Virtual violence includes first-person shooter games and other realistic video games and applications. Furthermore, the terms “aggression” and “violence” are not used interchangeably. For the purposes of this policy statement, human aggression is defined as any behavior intended to harm another person who does not want to be harmed. The harm can be psychological or physical. Violence is defined as aggression that has as its goal extreme physical harm, such as injury or death. For example, a snarling dog is behaving aggressively; once it bites, it has resorted to violence. A person who verbally abuses another would not be committing an act of violence by this definition. Thus, all violent acts are aggressive, but not all aggressive acts are violent.3 By analogy, passing a roaring monster as an avatar in a video game is experiencing virtual aggression and being shot to death in a first-person shooter game is experiencing virtual violence.
Although there is broad scientific consensus that virtual violence increases aggressive thoughts, feelings, and behaviors, there has been little public action to help mitigate children’s exposure to it.4 In fact, the single broadest legislative action taken by the state of California, which made it illegal to sell video games labeled for mature audiences to minors, was struck down by the US Supreme Court. It is important to note, however, that the ruling was not based on the absence of data linking media violence to aggression. Rather than rule on scientific merit, the Court invoked first-amendment protection for the games insofar as the Court construed their primary purpose to be to confer ideas and social messages.5 Currently, there is no federal authority governing content and ratings, which are issued by the Entertainment Software Ratings Board, compliance with which is optional for industry.
Evidence of the Impact of Virtual Violence
Since the first congressional hearings were held on the potential linkage between television violence and homicides in 1952, hundreds of studies exploring the effects of media violence have been conducted.6 Notably, over the ensuing decades, media violence has evolved to become both more prevalent and more intense.6
Some brief mention of the types of studies performed is necessary to set the stage for the conclusions that can be, and have been, drawn. Studies have been observational and experimental as well as laboratory and field based. End points have included aggressive thoughts, angry feelings, and actual observed or reported aggression. Finally, studies have assessed short- and long-term exposure and proximate or distant aggressive actions. Accordingly, the scientific landscape is complex, because researchers have used different methods on different populations over time. Although individual research approaches may have shortcomings, when one considers the overall body of research the linkage between virtual violence and aggression has been well supported and is robust.
One research challenge has been to conclude that laboratory aggression can act as a proxy for what may happen in the real world. Consider a typical laboratory study in which subjects are randomly assigned to play a violent or nonviolent video game. They are then assessed for their willingness to administer pain in the form of unpleasant sounds (eg, mixture of fingernails scratching on blackboards, dentist drills, blow horns, and fire alarms), at a decibel of their choice within the limits of a nondamaging range, to a person who, unbeknownst to the participants, is part of the research team. Those who played a violent video game administered the sounds at a higher level and for a longer period of time.7 Although it is true that the situation of having a pain-inflicting auditory device at one’s disposal does not occur in the real world, there is no reason to doubt the tendency or willingness to inflict pain would be less in the real world than in the laboratory, especially given study subjects’ awareness that they were being observed while in the laboratory.
It is true that an experimental, real-world study that links virtual violence with real-world violence has not been conducted. Such a study will never be undertaken for several reasons, including the fact that actual violence is, fortunately, so rare that an exceedingly large sample size would be needed, and inducing and observing actual violence by manipulating subjects would never pass ethical scrutiny. But experimental linkages between virtual violence and real-world aggression have been found. For example, a recent experimental study conducted in the real world motivated parents to change their children’s media diet by substituting prosocial programs in place of violent ones. This study found decreases in aggression and improvement in overall behavior.8
Understanding the risks of media violence can be complicated when research studies have found mixed results using varying methods. Fortunately, meta-analyses have been performed to combine the available research findings and to provide an overall estimate of the risks.9–11 Summarizing the results of >400 studies including violent media of all types, researchers found there was a significant association between exposure to media violence and aggressive behavior (effect size: 0.19; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.19–0.20), aggressive thoughts (effect size: 0.18; 95% CI: 0.17–0.19), angry feelings (effect size: 0.27; 95% CI: 0.24–0.30), and physiologic arousal (effect size: 0.26; 95% CI: 0.20–0.31).11 Another study performed a similar analysis focusing only on video games. The results, based on 140 such studies, found slightly larger negative effect sizes.10 Some contend, rightly, that these correlations are in the small to moderate range, but they are stronger than the associations between passive smoking and lung cancer, and many municipalities have banned smoking because of that risk.12
Putting the Findings Into Perspective
A national discussion regarding the risks of media violence is necessary and critical for the health of our children and youth. Unfortunately, media reports frequently present “both sides” of the media violence and aggression issue by pairing a research scientist with an industry expert or spokesperson or even a contrarian academic, which creates a false equivalency and the misperception that research data and scientific consensus are lacking. A sizable majority of media researchers both in pediatrics and psychology believe that existing data show a significant link between virtual violence and aggression.4 One might justifiably wonder why the contrarian position to media violence is so frequently presented when it is no longer presented for passive smoke exposure.
The full implications of virtual violence are best understood at a population level. Although the majority of Americans believe there is a causal relationship between screen violence and real-world aggression, most believe that they and their children are immune to these effects. The so-called third-person effect causes people to believe that other people, not themselves, but some small, susceptible fraction of people, are influenced in a way the majority of the population is not. Stipulating that this belief is true, even if it is assumed that only 2% of the public is induced to behave more aggressively after being exposed to violent media, it can be expected that 400 000 of the 20 million viewers of the latest violent blockbuster film will exhibit increased aggression after viewing the movie, at least for a short period of time. Surely, even that figure is large enough to warrant some public attention and action.
Pediatricians should consider making children’s “media diets” an essential part of all well-child examinations. In particular, emphasis must be placed on guiding the content of media and not only limiting quantity.13 Impartial ratings, such as those issued by Common Sense Media, can be used to help guide selection.
Parents should be mindful of what shows their children watch and which games they play. When possible, they should coplay games with their children so as to have a better sense of what the games entail. Young children (under the age of 6 years) need to be protected from virtual violence. Parents should understand that young children do not always distinguish fantasy from reality. Cartoon violence can seem very real, and it can have detrimental effects. Furthermore, first-person shooter games, in which killing others is the central theme, are not appropriate for any children.
On state and local levels, policy makers should consider promoting legislation that provides caregivers and children better and more specific information about the content of media of all forms, especially with regard to violence, and should enact laws that prohibit easy access to violent media for minors.
Pediatricians are encouraged to advocate for more child-positive media. Pediatricians should support and collaborate with the entertainment industry to create more shows and games for children of all ages that do not include violence, especially as a central theme. The American Academy of Pediatrics makes the following recommendations for the entertainment industry:
Avoid the glamorization of weapon carrying and the normalization of violence as an acceptable means of resolving conflict.
Eliminate the use of violence in a comic or sexual context or in any other situation in which violence is amusing, titillating, or trivialized.
Eliminate gratuitous portrayals of interpersonal violence and hateful, racist, misogynistic, or homophobic language or situations unless explicitly portraying how destructive such words and actions can be. Even so, violence does not belong in media developed for very young children.
If violence is used, it should be used thoughtfully as serious drama, always showing the pain and loss suffered by the victims and perpetrators.
Video games should not use human or other living targets or award points for killing, because this teaches children to associate pleasure and success with their ability to cause pain and suffering to others.
The news and information media should acknowledge the proven scientific connection between virtual violence and real-world aggression and the current consensus of credentialed experts in this field and should avoid equating unscientific opinions and industry marketing tracts with peer-reviewed and vetted scientific research.
The federal government should oversee the development of a robust, valid, reliable, and “parent-centric” rating system rather than relying on industry to do so.
Dimitri Christakis, MD, MPH – Former Council on Communications and Media Executive Committee Member
Council on Communications and Media Executive Committee, 2014–2015
David Hill, MD, Chairperson
Nusheen Ameenuddin, MD, MPH
Yolanda (Linda) Reid Chassiakos, MD
Corinn Corss, MD
Daniel Fagbuyi, MD
Jeffrey Hutchinson, MD
Alanna Levine, MD
Claire McCarthy, MD
Robert Mendelson, MD
Megan Moreno, MD, MSEd, MPH
Wendy Sue Swanson, MD, MBE
Kris Kaliebe, MD – American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
Jennifer Pomeranz, JD, MPH – American Public Health Association
Brian Wilcox, PhD – American Psychological Association
This document is copyrighted and is property of the American Academy of Pediatrics and its Board of Directors. All authors have filed conflict of interest statements with the American Academy of Pediatrics. Any conflicts have been resolved through a process approved by the Board of Directors. The American Academy of Pediatrics has neither solicited nor accepted any commercial involvement in the development of the content of this publication.
Policy statements from the American Academy of Pediatrics benefit from expertise and resources of liaisons and internal (AAP) and external reviewers. However, policy statements from the American Academy of Pediatrics may not reflect the views of the liaisons or the organizations or government agencies that they represent.
The guidance in this statement does not indicate an exclusive course of treatment or serve as a standard of medical care. Variations, taking into account individual circumstances, may be appropriate.
All policy statements from the American Academy of Pediatrics automatically expire 5 years after publication unless reaffirmed, revised, or retired at or before that time.
FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE: The author has indicated he has no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
FUNDING: No external funding.
POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST: The author has indicated he has no potential conflicts of interest to disclose.
COMPANION PAPER: A companion to this article can be found online at www.pediatrics.org/cgi/doi/10.1542/peds.2016-1358.
- Copyright © 2016 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
Negative effects of television on children essay Research paper .
College Argumentative Essay Violence on Television Effects Divorce affect children essay essay on tv violence Children and television violence essay writefiction web fc.
Essay on tv violence effect on children Design Synthesis Violence In Media Effects On Children Essays.
Tv violence essay examples The effects model is not grounded in theory .
The effect of ADHD on the life of an individual their family and How to Get Your Children Away from TV Steps with Pictures WeberRitterfeldMathiak Does Playing Violent Video.
Effect of media violence on children Essay Example Topics and .
Research paper video games a cause of violence and aggression Voluntary Action Orkney.
child abuse causes and effects essay Design Synthesis.
Essay on effects of television on children Essay writer.
violence in media essay The Guardian.
Children and tv violence essays Youth violence can ruin your life if you join any gang The media plays a big role also as a youth i appreciate this essay and atleast now .
Although research on the effects of media violence has been conducted for over years the first.
Write an essay on child abuse causes effects and solutions koxi concept info.
Help me do my essay impact of media violence INPIEQ.
Buy an essay paper Get someone write my paper the effect of tv Design Synthesis Child effects essay tv violence watching fortinbras foil hamlet essay global warming synthesis essay citing cases.
Study Skills Sample essay INPIEQ.
Violence in media effects on children essays violence on tv essay www gxart orgviolence in the media essay digital essaysviolence in the media.
Divorce affect children essay essay on tv violence Children and television violence essay writefiction web fc.
Sample Essays ReelRundown Is media violence damaging to kids.
Children tv violence essay Daily Mail Effects of media violence essay reportd web fc com College Argumentative Essay Violence on Television Effects.
internet addiction essay opsl ipnodns ruinformation technology essays internet addiction FC .
Help me do my essay impact of media violence dailynewsreports .
Do family characteristics affect children s health Wikiprogress media violence essays essays on media violence affecting Carpinteria Rural Friedrich.
Essay Positive and Negative Effects of Television Television Is television the leading cause of violence in.
Research Papers AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
Buy an essay paper Get someone write my paper the effect of tv INPIEQ.
Help me do my essay impact of media violence dailynewsreports Psychiatric Times Television affecting children essays kidakitap com Television affecting children essays kidakitap com.
Violence in media essay topics dailynewsreports web fc com Essays on media violence affecting children.
Effects of Tv Violence On Children AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
Media and youth violence essays on poverty Do video games cause violence Aug.
The Effect of Television Violence on Children and Teenagers Similar To College Argumentative Essay Violence on.
Essay on media violence affecting children Essay Writing Service Term paper Academic Writing Service .
Tv violence essay conclusion Children Watching Violence On TV Tv violence essay conclusion Children Watching Violence On TV.
Effect of child marriage essays Effects domestic violence children essays RedTide Motorsports aoimdns.
Effects domestic violence children essays.
Effect of Television Violence to Children CBA PL Essay on school shootings Someone to do my research paper Benton pl.
Help me do my essay impact of media violence dailynewsreports .
Charts Graphs on Video Games Youth Violence Violent Video INPIEQ Although research on the effects of media violence has been conducted for over years the first.
Media advantages disadvantages having children essay StudentShare.
Effects of gun violence on children and youth essay Effects of gun violence on children and youth essay.
essays on how tv affects children Marked by Teachers.
video games violence essay Essay About Violent Video Games Our Work Does Television Violence Affect.
essays on how tv affects children Carpinteria Rural Friedrich College Argumentative Essay Violence on Television Effects On December the National Rifle Association NRA blamed the.
Affect Of Media Violence On Children Young People Essay AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
Tv violence essay examples write essay my favourite teacher middot media violence essays essays on media violence affecting children biology.
Violence in media effects on children essays kujiyuumdns The Psychological Effects of Media Violence on Children and Adolescents Joanne Cantor Ph D Research on media violence is often misunderstood by the general .
essay on tv violence essay on media violence academic essay violent video games.
Video games and violence in children essay.
Effects of gun violence on children and youth essay Essays Online Effects of gun violence on children and youth essay Essays Online AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
Essay on violent video games effects on children.
Violence On Tv Essay aploon Violence On Tv Essay aploon essay on Does television violence affect children Daily Mail.
The Impact of TV Violence on Children and Adolescents Hampton Hopper Domestic Violence Theory Effects Interventions A literature WriteWork Domestic Violence Theory Effects Interventions A literature WriteWork.
Television has a negative influence on kids and should be limited Similar To College Argumentative Essay.
Essay on violent video games effects on children .
Violence on television doesnt effect children essay Media violence essay Betrayal essays go leak kameraschwenk beispiel essay Media violence essay Betrayal essays go leak kameraschwenk beispiel essay.
Violence in media effects on children essays Carpinteria Rural Friedrich.
Effects of tv violence on children essay essay on tv violence essay on media violence academic essay essay on tv violence essay on media violence academic essay.
media violence and children Ascend Surgical.
Violence in media effects on children essays StudentShare The Effects of Violent Video Games on Children Essay example.
words short essay on the Impact of Television on Children Carpinteria Rural Friedrich.
Divorce effect children essay .
Media violence essay Betrayal essays go leak kameraschwenk beispiel essay Media violence essay Betrayal essays go leak kameraschwenk beispiel essay.
Television A Blessing or a Curse A Level Media Studies Television Violence and the Effects on Children.
Studying the Effects of Playing Violent Video Games NYTimes com Carpinteria Rural Friedrich.
Anti social behaviour essay.
Cause and Effect Essay Examples http www sampleessay net cause.
Violence on tv essay Essay on othello Buzzle Disney Princesses are emotionally bonding with young girls Education Changemakers.
Although research on the effects of media violence has been conducted for over years the first Carpinteria Rural Friedrich.
Essay on media violence affecting children Essay Writing Service Carpinteria Rural Friedrich The longitudinal effects of parental involvement in media on child wellness Paper presented at the Society for Research in .
Top negative effects of video games on children AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
The effect of ADHD on the life of an individual their family and .
What is Media Literacy Definition Importance Examples INPIEQ.
Tv violence effect on children essay Custom paper Academic Service Limit children s screen time expert urges BBC News Limit children s screen time expert urges BBC News Essay Positive and Negative Effects of Television .
Anti social behaviour essay Research Aggression in school age children may have its origins Best Domestic Violence Quotes on Pinterest.
Effects of Television Violence on Children and Teenagers Free Essays Home FC Effects of Television Violence on Children and Teenagers Free Essays Home FC Carpinteria Rural Friedrich.
essays positive effects of television YouTube What type of essay do I write Many people believe.
Research Shows Violent Media Do Not Cause Violent Behavior .
essays on media violence affecting children order essay cartoonawareyviolenceblogspotcom Ascend Surgical.
Effects of cartoons on children essay Cause and Effect Obesity Writefix com Aggression and Violence in the Media essay writers for hire.
Divorce effect children essay INPIEQ.
essay on media violence essays on media violence affecting AcademicHelp net Domestic Violence and Women .
essays on how tv affects children Carpinteria Rural Friedrich Do family characteristics affect children s health Wikiprogress media violence essays essays on media violence affecting.
child abuse causes and effects essay comyr com.
Maryknoll Essay Contest for Students Tv violence essay conclusion Children Watching Violence On TV Tv violence essay conclusion Children Watching Violence On TV.
Argumentative essay on influnce of television Mass General Hospital .
Write an essay on child abuse causes effects and solutions.
THESIS ON IMPACT OF EDUCATION ON DOMESTIC VIOLENCE Sparkles Soft offers under stated Services Home FC INPIEQ.
Essay on effects of television on children Essay writer Write an essay on child abuse causes effects and solutions.
Child effects essay tv violence watching dravit si.
Need help do my essay media violence and its effect on children Need help do my essay media violence and its effect on children dravit si.
Essay on violent video games effects on children.
Media Effects Essay Carpinteria Rural Friedrich Need help do my essay media violence and its effect on children Need help do my essay media violence and its effect on children.
The problem of violence in video games GCSE English Marked by Livestrong com The Impact of Reality Shows on Children LIVESTRONG COM Debate Many people believe that television violence.
Essay about video games and violence dravit si What is Media Literacy Definition Importance Examples.
violence on television essay.
Television A Blessing or a Curse A Level Media Studies Mass General Hospital On December the National Rifle Association NRA blamed the media for promoting violent video games and movies and then cited these phenomena as the .
essays on how tv affects children.
video games violence essay Essay About Violent Video Games Our Work Does Television Violence Affect INPIEQ.
Research Papers Design Synthesis.
Effects of Tv Violence On Children.